Takashi Miike is one of the most satisfyingly perverse directors around.
Audition,
Ichi the Killer,
Visitor Q,
Gozu: all deliberately pushing at the boundaries of the acceptable, without resorting to cheap sleaze. One of his more extreme scenes, necrophillia with an incontinent corpse in
Visitor Q, is not done in an exploitative way, but as an ingredient in a subverse, witty contemplation, and a deliberate provocation. Beneath his acupunture needle-wielding, face-slice-offing protagonists,
Miike has the cinematic skill to pull off controversial films which would, in lesser hands, be consigned to the bargain bin. The
Yakuza genre of films from Japan is full of the standard stuff, but
Miike's Dead or Alive is a hyperactive, kinetic visual treat, which transcends the generic script and crude characterization. Likewise,
The Happiness of the Katakuris is a bizarre musical based on a luckless family running a bed and breakfast. Despite an unpromising premise,
Miike gives us an interesting take on the Japanese trait of the fear and shame of failure and a surprisingly touching portrait of family life. It is a rare director indeed that can have a film which features a sumo wrestler crushing his girlfriend when he dies during intercourse, followed by a beautiful shot showing the passing of the family's grandfather.
With an oeuvre as compelling as
Miike's, I was intrigued to discover that he was attempting a remake of a 1963 samurai film,
Jūsannin no Shikaku. Most people are familiar with
Jidaigeki films such as
The Seven Samurai and
Ronin, shot in a cool, rigorous style by directors such as
Akira Kurosawa, so for an artist as singular as
Miike, it seemed an interesting choice of project. The storyline follows the attempted assassination of a psychopathic brother of the
Shogun by a band of samurai hired by governmental officials. The deranged lord,
Naritsugu, is a thoroughly nasty piece of work, raping and murdering with abandon. The leader of the samurai band,
Shinzaemon, gathers a group of 11 more fighters and plans an ambush of
Naritsugu and his retinue.
Proceedings begin promisingly, with an authentic-looking
seppuku, and
Mikke's prowling camera is kept at an
Ozu-style low level. The main characters are introduced efficiently, and 1840s Japan looks suitably
Shogun-like. Fairly soon, one of the main shortcomings becomes apparent: the samurai are, probably by definition, too similar to make any individual impression. While this was arguably the case in
The Seven Samurai, at least there were only seven. Of the original 12, only a few stand out, with the rest disappearing into the background.
Naritsugu, as played by
Goro Inagaki, is a sinister, effete presence, contrasting nicely with the rough-hewn soldiers surrounding him. In a flash of typical
Miike, he is surrounded by the twitching, arrow-riddled bodies of the family of the official who committed suicide.
Never a director to rush things,
Miike allows the plot time to develop, but there isn't really enough material to stretch out. There are hints that the time of the samurai is passing, with frequent questioning of the
bushido code, and a few competently-staged swordfights, but none of the iconoclasm you would expect from the great man. The whole thing seems too 'straight' and conventional to mark it out as anything special. Even in
Miike's lesser films, the viewer knows they are in the presence of a master, but here,
he all but disappears behind the subject matter. There are hints at his genius- the scene mentioned earlier, and a brilliant POV sequence towards the end of a dying samurai watching his master kill and be killed.
On the way to the inevitable showdown, the band are joined by a hunter,
Kiga, who is the film's most interesting character. Ostensibly used as a critique of the samurai caste,
Kiga's character is possibly a mountain or forest spirit, and certainly survives severe injuries with little ill-effect. The much-vaunted final third of the film is an epic close quarters battle between the 13 assassins and 200 soldiers, set in a small village. The usual limitations of the genre are evident here: enemy soldiers are instantly killed or incapacitated by single slashes, and helpfully hold back, instead of rushing the heavily outnumbered heroes. The fight never comes across as a desperate struggle, has little flow and, surprisingly, less gore than you would imagine. The climax is predictable, but nicely done, with much crawling in the mud and refreshingly short dying words.
13 Assassins is a professional job and, from a different director, it would perhaps be enjoyable. However, coming as it does from the man who brought us some of the most provocative films of the last 20 years, it comes as a major disappointment. Another 2010
Miike film is
Ninja Kids!, a family film, which doesn't bode well for the future. Hopefully,
13 Assassins is not
Miike's bid for mainstream acceptance, but a
Salaryman Kintaro-style glitch. Cinema needs agent provocateurs like
Miike and
Lars von Trier to spice things up between the latest 3-D shitfest and
Michael Bay's latest atrocity.